What Is and What Should Never Be for being a really heartbreaking AU for Dean
Mystery Spot for the hilarity and black comedy of Dean's many deaths
A Very Supernatural Christmas for being such a delightfully twisted attempt at a Christmas episode (yikes at the body being dragged down the stairs in a sack with the little kid watching!), as well as the adorable flashbacks of course
Lazarus Rising for being the best SPN premiere IMO
On the Head of a Pin for the darkness and intensity of the Dean and Alistair scenes, and of course the angel storyline
Changing Channels for the show trying something different and being hilarious with it
Abandon All Hope for killing me with Ellen and Jo's deaths <3
This is hard to narrow down!
Mystery Spot for the hilarity and black comedy of Dean's many deaths
A Very Supernatural Christmas for being such a delightfully twisted attempt at a Christmas episode (yikes at the body being dragged down the stairs in a sack with the little kid watching!), as well as the adorable flashbacks of course
Lazarus Rising for being the best SPN premiere IMO
On the Head of a Pin for the darkness and intensity of the Dean and Alistair scenes, and of course the angel storyline
Changing Channels for the show trying something different and being hilarious with it
Abandon All Hope for killing me with Ellen and Jo's deaths <3