Toby would've been an excellent choice. He had plenty of reasons to dislike Alison/the girls, even if he eventually fell for Spencer. And it would've been much more emotionally devastating and the consequences would've been more long-lasting. Like...poor Spencer would never date again :) But I knew they'd never go there. Even if the show-runners wanted to, the network would've never allowed it.

I don't know what they did with Sasha's makeup in that flash-forward but Alison looked ridiculous. I hope they do a better job of trying to make her look older when we get to 6B. Spencer looked odd too but I think that was more clothing/hairstyle choice than makeup.