I love most of those choices! Halloween and Fear Itself especially are perfect one-off episodes to watch for the first time
I'm not sure about the musical though, I always feel like those one-off concept episodes are a bit too odd to introduce a newcomer to Buffy as they're not as representative of the average episode. Hmm now I'm curious about what people's first episode was, and whether anyone did watch something like Hush, The Body, or OMWF first and it made them want to see more :goes to edit that question in:
Hey :)
I'm not sure about the musical though, I always feel like those one-off concept episodes are a bit too odd to introduce a newcomer to Buffy as they're not as representative of the average episode. Hmm now I'm curious about what people's first episode was, and whether anyone did watch something like Hush, The Body, or OMWF first and it made them want to see more :goes to edit that question in: