I really love season 2. To be totally honest I struggled a bit with season 1 when so many of the episodes felt like kind of cliched MotW ones, and a bit samey. There was some good stuff that year with John and the family feel of course, but a lot of the episodes didn't really grab me in themselves. Also the writing seemed quite clunky at times, whereas season 2 was SUCH a huge leap of quality with so many flawess epiodes. Plus that was when they started doing something different with the format in episodes like The Usual Suspects and Tall Tales, instead of season 1's more straight retelling of famous urban legends