For the most part, I'm the same. For Season 1, I would replace Out of Mind with Nightmares as I liked the psychological aspect of that (reminded me of Restless). Season 2 is impossible to pick from for me but the ones you picked look good to me (although I'd add What's My Line in for a tie). I'm not a fan of The Wish and Doppelgangland, so personally I'd replace them with the two part Graduation Day. For Season 4, I'd put Hush as #2 and replace Pangs with Primevial. Once More With Feeling definitely is #1 and I'd replace Life Serial with Grave. And for Season 7, I'd replace Selfless with Chosen. Of course, these are all my opinions.

The whole list just reminds me how awesome BtVS was.